Can I see some I.D.

Years ago, when his eldest child was very young, my friend John had to travel a lot for work. He spent quite a bit of time in Korea and while he was gone his wife would do the daily tasks like grocery shopping and banking. When he was in town, he would run his share of errands. As someone who has travelled a lot, I too know that the person not traveling just figures that you've been having a good old time while they've been doing all the work.

So he was on one of these errands and the person behind the counter didn't know him and was asking for some identification. He had his hands full so first he put his son down on the counter and went to reach for his wallet. "Never mind", the woman behind the counter said, "I recognize your son."

I love that image of child as I.D.

I used to have two forms of I.D. and now have one.

When Maggie was in first grade, Elena and I would often go pick her up from school. If the weather was nice we would walk to the school and sit on a bench just outside Maggie's classroom window. Mrs. Eagleton, who we didn't know then, would stop by on her way to bus duty and chat with us. She mainly talked to Elena.

Elena was one form of I.D.. She was how people knew that I was connected to  Kim. Gene, the crossing guard, saw me walk the girls to school and he saw Kim walk the girls to school. He knew that each of us belonged to the girls. I think it threw him on days that we both took the kids to school.

Growing up it seemed as if the identification worked the other way. "Oh, you're Priscilla and Ira's son." And that's who I was.

I grew up in a small town where everyone knew each other.

The government, however, doesn't think that's enough. I started teaching at Oberlin College the year that Kim and I got married. I had to fill out all sorts of paper work including proof that I am a U.S. Citizen. I stood in an office with a woman who had known my dad since I was two. She told me she needed official documentation. I had worked for the college summers since I was sixteen working in the kitchens and teaching in the Upward Bound program.

Still not good enough. Eight years before this country was attacked I had to prove to a woman who had known my family more than thirty years that I was a U.S. citizen.

Yesterday I went to get license plates for a used car we bought. The agency had issued me my Driver's license but they would not accept that as valid I.D.. They needed my social security card as well. They had big signs every where saying they could no longer legally display our social security number on our Driver's license because the number can't be used for those purposes. They needed to identify me and they used my social security number internally so they required proof of social security number to register my car.

They sent me to the social security agency. A month or so ago I would have raised a fuss but I'm still not feeling up to it. At the social security agency I filled out a form and waited for my number to be called. The woman told me she would need some sort of I.D. to prove who I am. I gave her my passport issued by the federal government. She asked me for my Ohio driver's license.

You can't always hoist your child onto the counter as I.D., but I think we've lost something.

Published in: on March 31, 2006 at 8:16 am  Comments (5)  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://dearelena.wordpress.com/2006/03/31/can-i-see-some-id/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

5 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. […] Over at Dear Elena, there is an article on identification, and it set me to thinking about who I am. As my life has progressed, who I am has changed. During my life, I’ve had two identities which have really defined who I am. […]

  2. I recently registered my third child in the school system. The School District requires multiple forms of I.D. including the deed to your home. The fact that the District is currently educating two siblings who live in the same house with the same parents is irrelevant. I still have to prove that my son is a resident of the school district. His brothers can’t be used as a form of I.D.

    Maybe that’s why I love Mr. Raymont’s form of I.D. You’ll always be Elena’s dad and Maggie’s dad at Boulevard.

  3. Last year I lost my (Canadian) passport and had to get a replacement in a hurry because I was going overseas. I chose to pick it up at the local passport office because I could be sure to get it in ten days.

    I showed up with my barcode receipt, and the girl behind the counter went and retrieved my passport.

    And then she said: “I’ll need to see some ID.”

    Me, flabbergasted: “Er… I thought that was the ID.”

    Her, with a warning tone in her voice: “Well, this is a travel document, but in order to release it to you I have to see some ID.”

    Me, getting snarky: “Well, you know, I thought you could open the passport, look at the picture, look at my face and say ‘Hey, that’s the guy!’ You know — like you expect border control at every other country in the world to do?”

    Her, chilly as the Arctic: “That’s as may be, but I’ll still need to see some ID.”

    Me, exasperated: “All right, but what does it say that you trust the Alberta Driver’s License security process more than your own?”

    I still haven’t gotten over that one. =)

  4. Is there a bit of irony there? The same agency that won’t take your driver’s license, issued by THEM as ID sends you to another agency which uses the form the first agency won’t use as proper proof of who you are, so that you can get the cardboard sans-photo ID that will be accepted. Things that make you go hmmmmm…

  5. Elena, Officialdom would be technically certifiable as insane. It’s like the untrusting relationship between two countries that go to war. The paranoia runs deep while on a superficial level there are diplomatic smiles and sweet talk. Grin and bear it. It’s a database-driven world now.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: